Windows Forum / Windows Vista / Hardware / May 2008
SD (Secure Digital) Causes Blue Screen in Vista x64
|
|
Thread rating:  |
coljohnhannibalsmith - 12 Oct 2007 19:41 GMT To whom it may concern:
I have an Acer 5102 WLMi Notebook, which came with an (ENE CB 712/714/810) “5-in-1” Memory Card Reader. The important identifying information is provided below:
Acer Aspire 5102WLMi (w/o Bluetooth, Orbicam, or TV Tuner) Model No: BL51 AS5102WLMI-MCEEN-TL50/15.4 ACB/512M/100G US S/N: LXABH0J0116380F0B41601
The system came with Windows XP Media Center Edition loaded and I have upgraded the OS to Vista x64, thereby voiding the warranty. Vista x64 works very well; but when I try to install an SD card, Windows “Plug & Play” will reach various stages of installing the driver software before crashing with a Blue Screen, where the video is also scrambled, so it’s impossible to read the error message. This looks a lot like a "short-circuit" to me. My card reader was only designed to support SDA 1.1, which supports SD Cards up to 2GB. I used the correct card. I used a "SanDisk Extreme III 2GB SD Card," which I’m reasonably confident is not SDHC, so my unit, which was manufactured in November 2006, should be able to read it. I’ve read several online Blogs regarding SD cards causing BSODs in Vista. The articles point to 1.8v & 3.3v being activated when SD cards only use 3.3v. The symptoms are looking an awful lot to me like one of the system’s logic voltages is being pulled low, causing the OS Kernel to stop working. I have the related Hotfix from Microsoft installed; but I’m still having problems. It’s possible my Card Reader is bad, or perhaps I purchased a defective SD card. These are also possibilities. I would like to get this unit functioning properly under Vista x64, preferably with SDHC support. I have the correct drivers installed for this OS and Device Manager states “the device is working properly.” If I cannot get the device working properly, I would like to upgrade the internal Memory Card reader with one that is known to be compatible with Vista x64. I realize this will probably involve making changes to the motherboard; but I'm sure there is a vendor out there somewhere knowledgeable enough and willing to do this.
Thanks, John
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
Barb Bowman - 12 Oct 2007 20:25 GMT not sure this will help, but see ftp://ftp.support.acer-euro.com/notebook/vista_64bit/
>To whom it may concern: > [quoted text clipped - 36 lines] > >Thanks, John --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 12 Oct 2007 21:43 GMT Barb,
Thanks, for the reply. I checked out the ftp site. None of the folders listed my system and most were empty; however, undetered I checked each folder's contents individually and found the following file "CardReader_ENE_v3.00.04.zip," in one of the folders near the very bottom. This is the same Card Reader I use on my machine and looks like the same file that's on the "AcerPanAm" site, listed under the Aspire 5100 drivers folder simply as "Vista," not Vista x64; however I have verified that the extracted files from the AcerPamAm site do have x64 folders.
But the installer doesn't work in Vista x64. I had to drill down alternatively to either the "x64 Cardbus," or "x64 Card Reader" folders and install the drivers from Device Manager. When I did this they installed correctly and Device Manager reports all the various components of the device as working properly; but it still doesn't work. It may not be a problem with the drivers, it could be with Vista itself.
I am going to copy the extracted files to my flash drive and compare them to what I have at home. If the drivers are different, I'll try installing them and let you know what happened.
Nice detective work!
Thanks, John
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
Barb Bowman - 12 Oct 2007 23:13 GMT thanks for the update.
>Barb, > [quoted text clipped - 23 lines] > >Thanks, John --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 13 Oct 2007 07:24 GMT Barb,
I located the driver file in the "Travelmate 6292" folder. It was also located in one or two others. The drivers loaded successfully, then I was prompted to restart the computer, which I did. I installed the SD card and was prompted to format it. The screen went blank and came back on. I then got a window stating that Windows had shut down; but I was able to close that window and press "OK" to start the format. The format proceeded for about a minute, then I got a Blue Screen again, with scrambled video, just like before. I removed the SD card and performed a cold boot to reload Windows. When Windows reloaded I got the following error message:
Problem signature: Problem Event Name: BlueScreen OS Version: 6.0.6000.2.0.0.256.1 Locale ID: 1033
Additional information about the problem: BCCode: 1a BCP1: 0000000000003452 BCP2: 00000000001E0000 BCP3: FFFFF70000081508 BCP4: 0000000000000000 OS Version: 6_0_6000 Service Pack: 0_0 Product: 256_1
Files that help describe the problem: C:\Windows\Minidump\Mini101207-02.dmp C:\Users\John\AppData\Local\Temp\WER-41890-0.sysdata.xml C:\Users\John\AppData\Local\Temp\WERDBD9.tmp.version.txt
Read our privacy statement: 'Microsoft Online Crash Analysis' (http://go.microsoft.com/fwlink/?linkid=50163&clcid=0x0409)
I tried one more time with similar results.
BTW, I finally read the release notes for the previous drivers I was using and for the new drivers. It appears the drivers I was using before were for XP x64. Oddly enough, I was able to install these through Device Manager. At least this set was intended for Vista x64. I also learned from reading the release notes, that this set of drivers is intended to provide SDHC support. My card reader's still not working; but at least I know that my card reader can be updated for SDHC support, by drivers alone. Perhaps a Hotfix or a driver tweak will allow me to get the reader working. Fortunately, I don't think I'm going to need to modify the mother board anymore.
I have an active "Paid" trouble ticket open with Microsoft for this issue. If they provide me with a resolution, I will share it with all of you.
I'm really at a loss for what to try next. I'm pretty sure the drivers are correct. This is looking more and more like a Vista issue. I'm wondering if I should try a different brand of SD card, or just wait to hear back from MS. I'm also wondering how to "tweak" a driver. Device Manager states these drivers were built with "WinDDK." I guess I'll have to Google this to find out what this means. Can anyone describe what the rudimentary procedures are for tweaking a driver?
Thanks, John
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
Barb Bowman - 13 Oct 2007 09:41 GMT did MS support ask for the crash data? if not, when you email them again, tell them you have this info.
>Barb, > [quoted text clipped - 59 lines] > >Thanks, John --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 13 Oct 2007 08:55 GMT I Finally received an email from MS. They said to try it in Safe Mode and it worked. The device was completely stable; however, I was only able to perform a quick format using the default settings, which were FAT file system & 32KB allocation unit size. Is this normal?
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
Barb Bowman - 13 Oct 2007 09:40 GMT no, not normal. but it may help them diagnose the issue. please continue to keep us posted here. there are quite a few people having issues with these devices.
>I Finally received an email from MS. They said to try it in Safe Mode >and it worked. The device was completely stable; however, I was only >able to perform a quick format using the default settings, which were >FAT file system & 32KB allocation unit size. Is this normal? --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 16 Oct 2007 16:17 GMT I received another email from "Vivian" at MS last night. She said she analyzed the Minidump files I sent her as an attachment and stated that "ntoskernel.exe" was the affected OS file. Also, in her reply, she instructed me to restart the system in "Clean Boot" mode. This involves running "msconfig" and checking "Hide All" on the Services Tab, then pressing "Disable ALL;" then pressing "Disable ALL" on the Startup Tab, then pressing Apply, OK and restarting the system, also checking "Don't Show This Message Again," when I get the msconfig NAG window when Windows restarts. I then inserted the SD card and Windows did not detect it at all. I then checked Device Manager and found a yellow "Conflict" icon next to:"Storage Controllers\ENE PCI Secure Digital / MMC Card Reader Controller." I then pressed "Scan For Hardware Changes" in DM and the Conflict icon remained. Then I opened the Properties window for this device and read the following message in the "Device Status" window: "Windows cannot load the driver for this hardware. The driver may be corrupt or missing." I then attempted to reinstall the driver from the "DM Properties" window; but the Wizard reported that the device was up-to-date, almost immediately, leading me to believe that nothing was actually installed, since reinstalling the driver should have taken at least a couple of seconds. I then removed the SD Card and pressed "Scan For Hardware Changes" again and the Conflict icon remained. I then restarted the system in Normal mode and the Conflict icon remained. I then instructed DM to uninstall the driver and delete the driver software by checking the appropriate box in the confirmation window. Windows' "Plug & Play" started immediately and could not find the driver software, so I had to manually guide P&P to the correct folder, DM installed the driver successfully and the yellow conflict incon disappeared. I did not retest the SD card in Normal or Clean Boot mode, because I was composing a response email to Vivian at MS and a Blue Screen would have caused me to have to log back into Hotmail again. Besides, it was after 11:00 pm and I had had enough for one day.
BTW, Vivian also instructed me to run the "Memory Diagnostic Tool" and this would not work from either the Startup Search Window or the install disk. In both cases I received the message: "Info for the selected entry could not be loaded because the application is missing or corrupt," "boot\memtest.exe," Status: 0xc000000e. I drilled down to the appropriate folder and located the application "memtest.exe," Version: 6.0.6000.16386, Date Modified: 11/2/06 2:51 am, 377 KB. I checked the Permissions and System, Administrators, and Users all have Read & Execute permissions. These appear to be correct.
Vivian also had me run "MSINFO32" and save the file to the Desktop as a compressed file to email to her as an attachment, which I did.
**Please stay tuned for the next exciting installment of: "What the $#@!^& happened to my Memory Card Reader."
-John
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
Barb Bowman - 16 Oct 2007 17:01 GMT thanks for the update. can't wait for the next exciting "chapter" ;-)
>I received another email from "Vivian" at MS last night. She said she >analyzed the Minidump files I sent her as an attachment and stated that [quoted text clipped - 46 lines] > >-John --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 19 Oct 2007 18:52 GMT Vivian at MS next had me attempt to use the SD card in "Device" Clean Boot mode. This involves opening Device Manager and disabling all non-essential devices, which I did, inluding the other two components of the 5-in-1 card reader, which were not being used. When I inserted the SD card, the system Blue Sceened almost inmediately. So, it appears the problem is either with the driver or with Vista itself. I can't wait to hear the response from MS! BTW, Vivian said that if necessary she will open a separate Trouble Ticket for the "memtest.exe" problem, free of charge. This one definitely sounds like an MS isssue, so at least they're taking responsibility for it. I don't know if I'll ultimately get a resolution; but so far their service has been pretty good.
Anyway, I've learned a little bit about device driver troubleshooting. It apears the process is to test the device in Safe Mode and if stable, test again in Clean Boot mode. If stable, reenable applications and services until the device fails and you've found the culprit. If unstable in Clean Boot mode, test the device in Device Clean Boot mode. If stable, reenable devices until the device under consideration fails and again you've found you're culprit. If unstable, then the issue is either with the driver itself or the OS. Very interesting! This is where I am now.
If MS places the blame on the driver my next step will be to post the text of the .INF files here, for the drivers that aren't working and perhaps the original XP x32 drivers, which I've never tested; but assume must have worked when the unit shipped. Then with luck a knowledgeable person might be able to examine them and point out any differences that could potentially be the source of the problem. This set of drivers actually contains 4 components. The CardBus driver, the SD/MMC Card Reader, the MS/MS Pro Card Reader and the xD Card Reader. I intend to post the .INF files for all 4 devices for the failing driver set and a known good driver set, albeit for XP x32. I believe I have all the tools I need to edit drivers now. I've got the .CAB SDK, the Vista WDK, WINPE2 and the Express version of MS Visual Studio 2005 and all the relevant components. At this point all I'll need is a couple of hints to point me in the right direction. Wow, I never thought I'd get this deep into this mud hole, yikes!
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
Barb Bowman - 19 Oct 2007 19:14 GMT Wow, that's a lot of work for you to do. I do hope that this leads to a successful resolution. Please continue to keep us posted.
>Vivian at MS next had me attempt to use the SD card in "Device" Clean >Boot mode. This involves opening Device Manager and disabling all [quoted text clipped - 33 lines] >in the right direction. Wow, I never thought I'd get this deep into this >mud hole, yikes! --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 23 Oct 2007 20:48 GMT Well I just received another email from MS and they state that in addition to "ntoskernel.exe," "ntfs.sys" is also affected; so Vivian at MS had me run "chkdsk /f /r." I assume the '/r' part is an instruction to repair the file system if any errors are found. chkdsk took about 1 1/2 hours to run and found no errors. Vivian; however did find a problem in my BCD file. She said that "memtest.exe" was set to the wrong partition; so she had me run: "BCDEDIT /SET {memdiag} partion=c:" This completed successfully. I then ran the Memory Diagnostic Tool and restarted the system. The Memory Diagnostic Tool ran as expected and found no errors. Well at least I've gotten this problem out of the way. I'm not entirely surprised by this error, since I upgraded the hard drive on my Notebook to 160GB within days of upgrading the Vista x64. I did this by using a commercially available USB, Universal cloning kit; however instead of using the cloning software supplied by the manufacturer, I used the Acronis cloning software I downloaded from Seagate, who manufactured the drive. I incorrecctly performed the last step of the cloning process, which was to restart the Notebook with the cloned drive still attached. Instead I removed the drive before restarting. When I did, the original drive would not restart and I had to use the install disk to repair the drive, after which Vista x64 started normally. The same thing also occurred on the cloned drive when I replaced the original drive with it. Here's the reason this happened. The instructions for the cloning software supplied by the cloning kit manufacturer warned profusely about NOT leaving the cloned drive connected durring restart; so I removed the cloned drive prior to restart. Much to my chagrin, the Seagate Acronis cloning software instructed leaving the cloned drive connected durring restart. I didn't bother to read that far until I had the restart problem. I assumed the cloning process would be universal, so I assumed I would follow the same steps for the other application. I guess I learned "my lesson!"
Unfortunatey the SD Card issue still persists. Somehow Vivian at MS was able to determine that I had not disabled the ATI Display Driver durring Device Clean Boot Mode. I didn't disable this, because I thought the display would stop working. She asked me to make sure that the device uninstalled completely before testing the SD Card in this mode and if it didn't to make sure I installed the latest driver. She provided me with a link to an ATI driver on Acer's website, unfortunately it was for Vista NOT Vista x64. I had already encountered this problem when I originally started searching for x64 drivers and located the most up-to-date driver on ATI's website. BTW, it's running beautifully. I was able to get the Display Driver, The South Bridge Drivers and the Catalyst Control Panel for the "ATI Radeon 1100 card." Those of us with Aspire 5100 Notebooks have been waiting with baited breath for these to be released. Anyway they're there and they're working perfectly. I do recommend installing these in order though; starting with the Display Driver, then the South Bridge Drivers, then the Catalyst Control Panel.
Anyway, this time I disabled the ATI Display Driver along with everything else that could be disabled, without shutting down the system. The display continued to work in VGA mode. Then I inserted the SD Card again. It Blue Screened immediately, so now I have to wait for MS's next email to troubleshoot further.
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
Barb Bowman - 23 Oct 2007 22:45 GMT ouch. you've certainly been having quite a time with this. I do hope that the MS folks come up with a resolution.
>Then I inserted the >SD Card again. It Blue Screened immediately, so now I have to wait for >MS's next email to troubleshoot further. --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 27 Oct 2007 18:41 GMT I have started a parallel thread here:
http://www.vistax64.com/drivers/101609-how-tweek-drivers.html
I think my last post there may be of much interest, to those with that inclination.
-John
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
coljohnhannibalsmith - 04 Nov 2007 01:26 GMT Well here goes,
Since the last time I wrote I've had two more TS sessions with MS. Here's how they went:
Prior to the previous TS session, Vivian escalated my ticket to an Escalation Engineer named Emma. Emma had me perform a complete format of the C:\ drive and then a Complete PC Restore without checking the select box to "Repartition and Reformat to Match the Backup," suspecting that "chkdsk" may have missed something. The system Blue Screed as before when I inserted the SD Card; so during the last TS session, she had me perform an "inplace-upgrade." This involves having Windows reinstall the system files from the install disk. This is supposed to leave your files and settings alone; but rewrites the Registry and deletes all the Windows Updates. It also forced me to reactivate, which I could not do online, since I have a wireless Internet connection through T-Mobile, which could not be launched from the Activation window. "God is this a buggy piece of @#$!%?" They're using me as an Alpha Tester and have made me pay $189.00 plus the $59.00 support fee for the privilege. They should be paying me as an SW Tester. I've got half a mind to file charges with the Department of Labor Standards Enforcement for unpaid wages! Then again, maybe I only have half a mind, which is far more likely.
Oh, BTW I also got a nasty message in the lower right corner of the Desktop that read: "This copy of Windows is not Genuine." This remained even after re-activation. Fortunately this went away after a couple of restarts.
Then I inserted the SD Card and held my breath. "Plug and Play" started immediately and placed a balloon on my Desktop stating: "Installing Software." This never happened before! Shortly thereafter, that went away and P&P placed another balloon on my Desktop stating:
"Secure Digital_MMC_Drive. Device Driver Software Installed Successfully."
This took at least a minute and nothing. No Blue Screen, no Dialog Boxes stating that some critical Windows component, like "Windows Explorer" had stopped working; so I opened the SD Card in "Computer" and was able to store files in it. I was also able to successfully perform Quick & Full Formats in FAT, FAT32 & NTFS and store files on the card in each of these formats. By this time I'm wiping the sweat off of my brow and daring to think that I've finally achieved success; but this was short lived. During all of this I was still connected to the Internet and one of my applications installed an update. I was persuaded to restart, which I did, with the SD Card still inserted. When Windows tried to launch the Desktop the system Blue Screened. I then removed the SD Card and Cold Booted. I started Windows normally, then reinserted the SD Card after Windows had completely loaded the Desktop. A dialog Box popped up stating that my HD Soft Conn Modem had stopped working; but I closed it and persevered. I was prompted to format the SD card and when I clicked "OK" another Blue Screen.
Anyway, I got a little farther along this time. Apparently, when Windows is first installed the Memory Card Reader Driver and Vista x64 are compatible; but this relationship doesn't last long. For some reason this relationship deteriorates relatively quickly in human time; however more slowly in processor time.
Emma says she thinks her manger will let her ship me a Retail Version of Vista x64; but I'm not sure what this is supposed to accomplish. At this point it appears MS is trying "Hail Mary" passes instead of trying to fix the problem. At this point I don't care. I just want to use my damn computer for something other than a paperweight.
-John
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
Barb Bowman - 04 Nov 2007 10:19 GMT do you know what the update was? did you try going into device manager and doing a driver rollback? (and or a system restore?)
this is extremely painful to read and has to be much worse for you, and I admire you patience.
>During all of this I was still connected to the Internet >and one of my applications installed an update. I was persuaded to [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] >working; but I closed it and persevered. I was prompted to format the >SD card and when I clicked "OK" another Blue Screen. --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 04 Nov 2007 14:47 GMT Barb Bowman;503159 Wrote:
> do you know what the update was? did you try going into device > manager and doing a driver rollback? (and or a system restore?) [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] > (http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx) > 'Barb's Connected World' (http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/) Hum...
The system only works temporarily with no updates loaded. I forget which application downloaded and installed an upgrade, but it wasn't a Windows Update and it wasn't driver related. I think it was one of my Firefox add-ons. Why one of these would require a restart I can't explain; but I was prompted for a system restart afterward and did so. That's when my system Blue Screened. I don't believe the application upgrade is responsible, since the problem persists in clean boot mode.
A driver rollback is a non-starter. I'm using the only Vista x64 drivers available and I've done many system restores. Something else appears to be going on. My theory at this point is that there is some instability in "ntfs.sys" that my driver somehow manages to trigger and this in turn causes a cascade effect, that eventually causes "ntoskernel.exe" to fail.
The only good thing I think that can come out of receiving a free Retail version, as the MS engineer suggested is that there may be some system file differences between the retail and the OEM versions. If this is so, performing an inplace-upgrade with the retail version may solve the problem, then again maybe not.
I suspect in the end MS will just need to add or modify a couple lines of code in ntfs.sys to solve the problem.
-John
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
Barb Bowman - 04 Nov 2007 17:20 GMT I can't imagine that the core files would be different. What are the file properties of ntfs.sys on your system? what is the status of the digital certificate?
>The only good thing I think that can come out of receiving a free >Retail version, as the MS engineer suggested is that there may be some [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] >I suspect in the end MS will just need to add or modify a couple lines >of code in ntfs.sys to solve the problem. --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 06 Nov 2007 20:57 GMT I'll post the core file info shortly,
I'm away from my Laptop right now. By digital certificate, I assume you mean for the driver set? These appear to be correctly signed. I received no warning message when installing and I've checked Device Manager and the driver manufacturer "ENE Technologies" is displayed.
Yesterday, I read the tutorial section regarding System Files, which covered some of the TS steps I've been performing with MS at the following link:
http://www.vistax64.com/tutorials/88236-repair-install-vista.html
It states the following if an "inplace-upgrade" fails to resolve the your issue:
"NOTE: If Vista is still not working properly afterwards, then a Clean Install would be recommended."
Since I already had my configuration backed up on an external HDD, I decided to give this a try and not only did the issue persist, but I got a BSOD when Windows tried to load for the first time and had to restart the install from the beginning and I got another BSOD after the first restart after the Windows Desktop completely loaded, even before inserting the SD Card. I briefly scanned the crash details and they appeared very similar to those caused by the SD Card.
This is very strange. I didn't get BSODs when cloning the 160GB drive from my original 100GB drive; but I got BSODs both times when performing a clean install to the 160GB drive. It's also strange that it appears to only affect one device. I think what I'll have to do next is reinstall my 100GB drive, perform a clean install and wait to see if I get BSODs durring the install or if not and when inserting the SD Card. This may expose an incompatibility in my new HDD; but then again, the OS and drivers are already mounted in RAM. The memory Diagnostic Tool reports no errors after several passes.
I received another email from Emma, after having done the clean install and she suggested uninstalling Firefox and collecting the Dump files again. I nearly lost it! Apparently it seems she's forgotten that we TS'd the system in Clean Boot mode. She must now think that Firefox's downloading and installation of an update is causing the problem. It seems to me that would be pretty difficult for an unrelated & unmounted application to do and I expressed as much to her. I also informed her that the problem persisted and displayed additional symptoms after a clean install.
I'm losing my faith in this engineer. She keeps asking me to do things over again, that don't appear to make sense with respect to the steps we've already taken together. Also, her English is barely better than pigeon. She appears to be located in mainland China. I've probably got enough energy left to check for the same problems with another drive, then if I still can't get a resolution I'm going to contact a Laptop repair company and let them give it a try.
Barb,
Do you know of any reputable companies that can handle Latop repair of this complexity?
Thanks, John
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
coljohnhannibalsmith - 07 Nov 2007 09:33 GMT So here's the latest,
I performed a Clean Install of Vista x64 on my old 100GB drive. I got BSODs after install and BSODs after inserting the SD Card, just like on my new drive. I did not load any other programs other than Windows and the Card Reader Drivers. So, at least I know my new HDD is not at fault. Then I loaded Vista x32 from the Acer upgrade disk. I had no BSOD problems during or after install and I restarted repeatedly to stress test the install, still no problems. I then inserted the SD Card and it worked flawlessly. I was able to perform quick and full formats in all three file systems, FAT, FAT 32 & NTFS. I intentionally left the SD Card inserted and restarted repeatedly. No further problems. It certainly appears that Vista x64 is just a buggy, unstable "bowl of sugar."
Thank You Microsoft!
Now all I have to do is do battle with their incompetent engineer. I'm very close to asking MS to replace her. I have very little patience left.
-John
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
Barb Bowman - 07 Nov 2007 10:13 GMT Although I don't normally recommend flashing the BIOS unless there is a real problem, it "appears" there is a new BIOS for your system from 11/1 at ftp://ftp.support.acer-euro.com/notebook/aspire_5100/bios/
(and you do need to understand that there is some risk in flashing a BIOS, altho I've done it many times myself on various systems.)
Some of us were/are having media reader issues on Acer's Ferrari 4000 (and 5000).
I resolved most of my issues with a BIOS update for the 4000 (see http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/2007/10/25/Updating+Acer+Ferrari+X64+Ult imate+With+New+BIOS.aspx for my tale of woe).
Your chronology of interaction with the MS engineer is depressing. I'm going to send it around to a few PSS and other folks I know at MS. While I doubt they will comment, I will make them aware of your bad experience.
>So here's the latest, > [quoted text clipped - 18 lines] > >-John --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 07 Nov 2007 20:43 GMT Thank you for your assistance,
I've flashed many BIOs myself and am aware of the dangers. Thanks for the caveat. The greatest danger is from power interruption during a flash; however corrupted and incorrect files can also be a danger. I am currently using v3.05 from the AcerPanAm.com site; so this will be the 2nd flash for me. I've noticed this is the second time you've referred me to a European site. Do they generally release more quickly there than here in the US? Anyway, the model #5100 looks correct and the latest version appears to be v3.10, which is consistent with the previous verion numbers. I will try it after reading your blog and the "release notes," if there are any.
It appears the next step for me is to perform a Clean Install again on my new drive and collect the crash data and dump files from the install BSOD, then save the crash data and dump files from the SD Card BSOD and forward them to MS with the reminder that these were obatined with no other software than the OS itself loaded from the first crash & the OS plus Card Reader Drivers from the second crash. It is my current theory that the causes are the same. If the files are text files, which I believe some of them are and they are small enough, I will also post them here with appropriate labeling, so that all may inspect them and that my scientific method of discovery may be well documented. When I'm further along toward a resoltion I will post the actual MS case number, so that all may inspect.
I'm really convinced the problem is with NTFS.SYS. I've been playing with the idea of substituting the NTFS.SYS file from XP x64. I don't know if this is even possible, because it may call different subroutines or differently named subroutines than the Vista x64 version; but it would be quite a coup if it worked; however I'll try flashing the BIOS first.
As an aside, Vista x32 will only see 2GB of my 4GB ram even though it's supposed to be capable of addressing 128GB Ram. Any thoughts on this?
-John
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
Barb Bowman - 07 Nov 2007 21:16 GMT 1. I don't even both with the US Acer site when looking for drivers and updates. I think they point everyone to the European ftp site on one of the links anyway.
2. The clean install and info gathering sounds like a good triage step.
3. I think you will be prevented from substituting a system file from XP x64
4. wondering about http://support.microsoft.com/default.aspx/kb/930261
5. see BIOS settings and see if there is a memory re-mapping setting.
>Thank you for your assistance, > [quoted text clipped - 33 lines] > >-John --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 08 Nov 2007 09:21 GMT I already have KB929777 installed, and I have an ATI Graphics Card not an NVIDIA; but it does appear the error is ram related. It took me a while, but I finally figured out why you're leaning in this direction. The Card Reader was stable with Vista x32 only seeing 2GB ram. So, after recollecting the crash data I yanked the second memory stick and guess what. The Card Reader works rock solid in Vista x64. It's looking now like the Card Reader and the upper 2GB of ram are trying to share the same address space. I would have thought Device Manager would catch the conflict, but I guess not. I'm fairly certain my BIOS doesn't have a memory remapping feature; but this can be done in Device Manager can't it?
BTW, I haven't flashed the BIOS chip with the new version yet; but I'll check for this feature as soon as I do.
-John
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
Barb Bowman - 08 Nov 2007 10:38 GMT You would have to remap in BIOS. Acer is pretty much ignoring any requests for fixes for x64 compatibility fixes, but if you find after flashing the new BIOS there is no support, you should still contact them and add another voice/complaint.
>I already have KB929777 installed, and I have an ATI Graphics Card not >an NVIDIA; but it does appear the error is ram related. It took me a [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] > >-John --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 08 Nov 2007 17:46 GMT Barb Bowman;507241 Wrote:
> You would have to remap in BIOS. Acer is pretty much ignoring any > requests for fixes for x64 compatibility fixes, but if you find [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > (http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx) > 'Barb's Connected World' (http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/) Ah yes the BIOS,
The BIOS has two versions a DOS version and a Windows version. The README file states that you can launch each version in its appropriate environment. When I tried to launch the Windows version, I got an "Error 1275" stating:
"The Driver could not be loaded."
The text of the error message said to "check administrator privileges." Well I'm the administrator and I have User Account Control turned off and Data Execution Prevention in the default setting, which is to monitor Windows Services only NOT Programs; so this certainly isn't the cause.
I then launched a DOS window and attempted to run both the Windows and the DOS versions of the installer. I received error messages both times. I believe when I tried to run the DOS version, I simply got a gereric error message stating an incompatibility issue. If my memory serves me correctly, when I tried to run the Windows version from the DOS window, I got an error message stating that the application is not compatible with 64 bit OSs. This makes sense, since Acer is trying their best, NOT to offer any x64 support. What I'm going to try next is to reinstall my old 100GB drive with Vista x32 on it and attempt to load the new BIOS from there. My last BIOS flash was done from XP x32.
BTW, I checked Device Manager and it appears there's an option to modify resources; but it's greyed-out and it also appears greyed-out for other unrelated components in DM as well. I wonder what bedeviled MS to disable this feature and if there's any way to turn it back on? What knuckleheads! When you deliver an unfinished product to the public, you "DON'T" disable TS features.
Oh, and Emma from MS wrote back again, she said she wanted me to send her the crash data and data from MSIFNO32, from after I performed the Clean Install, which makes sense; but then, she said we would "update the drivers one by one." This begs the questions: "Why would we need to update any drivers at all, especially more than one, since I'm getting BSODs immediately after install, before loading the SD Card Drivers; which means the only drivers being loaded are those supplied by the OS itself and when I get the SD Card BSODs, the only drivers loaded are those for the Memory Card Reader Plus the OS and I have the latest Memory Card Reader Drivers and she already knows that.
I haven't told her I've TS'd the problem to the upper 2GB of ram yet; but I'm wondering if she'd even understand if I did.
Weeeee...........:party:
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
Barb Bowman - 08 Nov 2007 22:02 GMT so you're good with my workaround?
>Barb Bowman;507241 Wrote: >> You would have to remap in BIOS. Acer is pretty much ignoring any [quoted text clipped - 58 lines] > >Weeeee...........:party: --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 08 Nov 2007 19:53 GMT Finally had time to read:
I resolved most of my issues with a BIOS update for the 4000 (see 'Barb's Connected World - Updating Acer Ferrari x64 Ultimate with new BIOS' (http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/2007/10/25/Updating+Acer+Ferrari+X64+Ult imate+With+New+BIOS.aspx) for my tale of woe).
I see you had the same problem and found a work around for it.
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
coljohnhannibalsmith - 09 Nov 2007 14:19 GMT I flashed the BIOS. The system still Blue Screens after I insert the SD Card and there is still no support for memory remapping.
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
Barb Bowman - 09 Nov 2007 16:38 GMT yuck. I can't think of anything else to suggest other than hounding Acer for better x64 support.
>I flashed the BIOS. The system still Blue Screens after I insert the SD >Card and there is still no support for memory remapping. --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 09 Nov 2007 19:23 GMT I've just sent Acer a request for email support. I've phrased it in such a way that it shouldn't violate their support policies. I haven't told them that I can't even get the unit to see the upper 2GB ram in Vista; but they don't need to know that. The email follows below:
Subject: Use of ENE Memory Card Reader causes BSODs with 4GB ram installed.
Acer Aspire 5102WLMi w/o Bluetooth, Orbicam, or TV Tuner Model No: BL51 AS5102WLMI-MCEEN-TL50/15.4 ACB/512M/100G US S/N: LXABH0J0116380F0B41601 O/S: Vista Home Premium. Date of Purchase: 2/29/2007
I recently upgraded to the Vista Home Premium version supplied to me by Acer through the Vista Upgrade Program, that my unit qualified for.
I can only use the internal ENE Memory Card Reader with 2GB ram installed. When I install the upper 2GB ram, my system Blue Screens when I attempt to use the Card Reader.
The crash data follows below:
Problem signature: Problem Event Name: BlueScreen OS Version: 6.0.6000.2.0.0.256.1 Locale ID: 1033
Additional information about the problem: BCCode: 1a BCP1: 0000000000003452 BCP2: 00000000001E0000 BCP3: FFFFF70000081508 BCP4: 0000000000000000 OS Version: 6_0_6000 Service Pack: 0_0 Product: 256_1
Files that help describe the problem: C:\Windows\Minidump\Mini101207-02.dmp C:\Users\John\AppData\Local\Temp\WER-41890-0.sysdata.xml C:\Users\John\AppData\Local\Temp\WERDBD9.tmp.version.txt
It is my opinion that this device shares memory mapping with the upper 2GB ram. I also suspect this will require a BIOS rewrite to remap the device or a BIOS rewrite to add memory remapping ability to the BIOS itself. Both highly desireable!
This is a "Hail Mary" play. Hopefully "meine kleine weisse Lüge" will generate a productive result.
-John
PS., I called Acer this morning and the phone tech said to download the "chipset drivers" to get the unit to see the upper 2GB ram in Vista x32. I've downloaded and installed the most recent set from "amd.ati.com;" but they did not slove the problem. I haven't tried downloading and installing the set from the AcerPanAm.com site yet.
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
coljohnhannibalsmith - 09 Nov 2007 19:34 GMT Opps:
I think I'm screwed, when they see this:
OS Version: 6_0_6000 Service Pack: 0_0 Product: 256_1
I suppose I can always tell them I'm having the same problem on a similar unit, or on a different drive with the x64 OS installed and provided them with the wrong crash data set and promise to supply them with correct data set.
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
Barb Bowman - 09 Nov 2007 20:33 GMT they may not even notice. more likely they will ask you if the RAM is genuine Acer brand RAM and then tell you, sorry, you need official Acer RAM.
>Opps: > [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] >provided them with the wrong crash data set and promise to supply them >with correct data set. --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 09 Nov 2007 20:48 GMT That's fine. I'll just tell them it's Acer ram. If the push me, I'll go out and buy some.
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
Barb Bowman - 10 Nov 2007 10:27 GMT Good luck. I DO hope you are successful.
>That's fine. I'll just tell them it's Acer ram. If the push me, I'll >go out and buy some. --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 15 Nov 2007 00:19 GMT Third Party BIOS upgrade:
I've come across an interesting website while searching on Google:
'eSupport.com - scan.esupport.com -' (http://scan.esupport.com/?CFID=378388&CFTOKEN=25298523)
It appears to offer 3rd party BIOS upgrades, which may offer a solution to my problem. I suspect however; that most of their business is from people who have older machines. They do some some interesting claims:
**eSupport is the world's oldest and largest provider of BIOS Upgrades with nearly 20 years of unparalleled excellence in the industry.
**Option To Assign IRQ's.
If these folks don't have a BIOS upgrade for my system, I suspect they might be able to write one or direct me to someone who can.
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
Barb Bowman - 15 Nov 2007 11:10 GMT I'd personally stay away from non manufacturer's BIOS. You can't lose anything by making an inquiry, but rather than toast a machine, I'd buy an external card reader.
>Third Party BIOS upgrade: > [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] >If these folks don't have a BIOS upgrade for my system, I suspect they >might be able to write one or direct me to someone who can. --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 19 Nov 2007 21:24 GMT I have been communicating with a Dan at Ircona a distributor of the Phoenix BIOS and he states that it would cost about $1000.00/day for the development effort involved in a BIOS rewrite. He suggested another strategy. He suggested modifying the E820 table after BIOS completes but before the OS loads. He states that this can be done by modifying the boot sector to intercept the Windows load and modify the E820 table before allowing Windows to finish loading.
This sounds like very technical stuff! Does anyone know what an E820 table is and how I would go about writing a program to do what Dan suggested above or is anyone out there qualified to do this?
Thanks, John
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
Barb Bowman - 19 Nov 2007 22:15 GMT I'll wish you the best of luck with this one..
>I have been communicating with a Dan at Ircona a distributor of the >Phoenix BIOS and he states that it would cost about $1000.00/day for the [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] > >Thanks, John --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 28 Dec 2007 16:14 GMT Solved, well almost.....
I purchaed another HDD on which I installed Ubuntu 7.10 "Gusty Gibbon" AMD64 Alternate Install CD.
The current release of Ubuntu has none of the afore mentioned problems with my "ENE 5-in-1" Memory Card Reader. It recognized the device immediately and automounted an 8GB Class 6 SDHC card. So at least I know the problem is software NOT hardware related. Also, since the SD Card Reader Driver is part of the Ubuntu Kernel, the source code is available; so I think, all I have to do to get this to work in Vista, if a future Vista or BIOS update doesn't fix the problem is install the "free" Trolltech Qt4 C++ development tools for Windows, which I assume supports the AMD64 platform, since the Linux version does and compile and install it in Vista, like any other driver. So not only do I know more about the problem; but now I have more than one option for solving it in Vista.
BTW, I've posted the results of my experiences on one of the the Ubuntu Support Forums on the following thread:
https://answers.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+question/20436
The 'business" portion of which, I've posted below:
cyberfella,
Just wanted to provide you and anyone else who reads this thread with an update:
While experimenting in Gutsy I noticed the size of the Swap file was ~6.3GB in Vista it's ~7.5GB, so I though I'd better buy an 8GB SD card. So, yesterday I walked accross the street to Fry's Electronics and purchased a "PQI" 8GB "Class 6" (20MB/s R/W) SD card, with a "Lifetime Warranty." This set me back $69.95 +tax, which is 8.25% here in Los Angeles. Patriot, sells a similar card, with a Lifetime warranty, for $59.95 +tax; but they were out of stock. This sure beats the heck out of $189.95 +tax for the Sandisk Extreme III cards. Anyway, I didn't even know if my internal reader was SDHC compliant; so I made sure I could return the card to the store if it didn't work and made sure I preserved the packaging.
When I got home I booted up "Good Ol' Gutsy," held my breath and inserted the SD card. It mounted almost immediately, leaving a beautiful SD icon on the Desktop. I opened the SD folder and made sure I could store a file in it then backed out and launched "GParted." I unmounted the card, which is "/dev/mmcblk9p1" on my system, deleted the original partition, created a new partition and formated it in "Linux Swap." This completed successfully. I then executed the instructions in the thread you pointed me to, which went something like:
"sudo swapon -p 32767 /dev/mmcblk9p1"
This completed successfully.
I then rebooted....
What I experienced next was almost better than sex... "Dolce santa madre di Dios, countach, whoooosh!!!!"
I've never seen Grub load so fast.
After the boot phase where Grub counts down to allow you to press Escape for a boot menu, the Verbose portion of the boot that displays what is written to the Kernel Log (kern.log) just flashed by. The screen blinked twice and and the sliding bar animation loaded almost immediately and even this took less than 5 seconds to complete. Then the Login Screen came up next and I logged in as usual. Before I could blink an eye, the Desktop loaded.
I tried performing the normal file, folder and application access tasks that are associated with any session; such as, opening files, folders, pulling down menus and launching applications. All of this and even my Screen Saver ran faster. I'm so so very glad I ignored your advice; however, I think a "RAID 0" configuration is a good idea. My next Laptop will have the following characteristics:
**17" Display.
**Dual SSD NAND Solid State HDDs in a "RAID 0" configuration; turning their native 50/45 MBs R/W speed into 100 MBs.
**Intel "Core 2 Extreme Quad Processor" or AMD equivalent, if they ever come out with one...
**x2 NVIDIA Graphics Cards or Chipsets in the case of Laptops to drive the Display or AMD equivalent.
**8GB Ram. Preferably Dual Port DDR3 at 800MHz, which I'm not sure even exists yet.
BTW, I also disagree about your assessment, that SD Cards cannot survive for long in this application. Microsoft's documentation states that their testing suggests that SD Cards can survive for 10 years being used this way. I got that from their own wedbsite. Also, the SD Card R/W mechanism is designed to SPREAD the writes evenly on the entire address space on the card; though I'm not sure if this is accomplished in hardware, software or both.
Well, I hope this puts this argument to rest and thanks again for directing me to this thread:
'How to: ReadyBoost with Ubuntu Linux - Ubuntu Forums' (http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=395435)
-John
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
Barb Bowman - 28 Dec 2007 21:18 GMT You've done an impressive amount of work on this. I am going to pass this on to some folks at MS.
>Solved, well almost..... > [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] >Vista, like any other driver. So not only do I know more about the >problem; but now I have more than one option for solving it in Vista. <snip> --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
Barb Bowman - 28 Dec 2007 21:22 GMT BTW, I would be curious as to whether Vista SP1 has any impact on your issue.
>Solved, well almost..... --
Barb Bowman MS Windows-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
coljohnhannibalsmith - 28 Dec 2007 22:40 GMT To the best of my understanding, SP1 is due in late January and the current release schedule for BIOS updates for my unit has been about 90 days. Since the last update was released on Oct 24th, 2007, the next one will be due around the same time.
I'll try to make sure I test after installing each, to isolate this further.
-John
 Signature coljohnhannibalsmith
I love it when a plan comes together. It keeps me "on the jazz!"
morrallas - 21 Apr 2008 15:04 GMT Here same problem with MSI PR200 (MS-1221) with Core 2 Duo T8100 and 4 GB RAM, with Vista Business x64 SP1. This notebook has ENE card reader, and with drivers version 3.00.04 (2007-03-01) I'm suffering BSOD randomly. With drivers uninstalled the system seems totally stable. Any news around this problem?
 Signature morrallas
Barb Bowman - 21 Apr 2008 21:24 GMT BIOS update from MSI?
>Here same problem with MSI PR200 (MS-1221) with Core 2 Duo T8100 and 4 >GB RAM, with Vista Business x64 SP1. This notebook has ENE card reader, >and with drivers version 3.00.04 (2007-03-01) I'm suffering BSOD >randomly. With drivers uninstalled the system seems totally stable. >Any news around this problem? --
Barb Bowman MS-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
wh1t3w0lf - 05 May 2008 19:25 GMT The same problem here ! acer travelmate 6292, vista ultimate x64 sp1. Reinstalled, latest drivers, bios updated. still no luck.
 Signature wh1t3w0lf
morrallas - 23 May 2008 16:12 GMT Solved with latest drivers version found on http://www.station-drivers.com/page/ene-tech.htm
Extracted from the drivers changelog: ===== Release note ===== Version : 2.00.04 (SD), 2.00.03 (MS) Date : 2007-07-09 1. For Vista64 ,new DMA way to support when system memory upper 4G.
 Signature morrallas
Barb Bowman - 23 May 2008 18:39 GMT thanks for reporting back and sharing the good news and the link!
>Solved with latest drivers version found on >http://www.station-drivers.com/page/ene-tech.htm [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] >Date : 2007-07-09 >1. For Vista64 ,new DMA way to support when system memory upper 4G. --
Barb Bowman MS-MVP http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone/meetexperts/bowman.mspx http://blogs.digitalmediaphile.com/barb/
wh1t3w0lf - 23 May 2008 16:41 GMT Worked for me ! thank you very much for the link !
 Signature wh1t3w0lf
|
|
|